Skip to content
Theology & God

Did God Create Evil? Isaiah 45:7 Explained

Rebecca Foster
Rebecca Foster · Biblical Studies Contributor
god and evil

Quick Answer: God did not create evil. Evil is not a substance, but a corruption of good. Isaiah 45:7 refers to God creating calamity or disaster as judgment, not moral sin.

Did God create evil? It is a question that hits hard when we face tragedy. We see a world full of violence and disease.

If God created all things (Colossians 1:16), does that trace evil back to His design? Skeptics use this dilemma as a weapon against the Christian faith. They argue that if God created evil, He is cruel, and if He cannot stop it, He is weak.

To find clarity, we have to look closely at Scripture. We need to define what evil actually is. Only then can we understand why God is not the author of sin.

A Pastoral Note: I sat with a grieving father last month who just lost his son. He looked at me, eyes red, and asked why God designed a world so full of death. Philosophy doesn’t help in the ICU. The truth is, God didn’t design the darkness—but He didn’t stay safely away from it, either. When the grief is choking you, the only comfort is looking at the cross and seeing a God who climbed right into the suffering with us.

What Is Evil?

did god create evil bible

People often talk about evil as if it were a physical thing. We picture it as a dark cosmic energy poured into the universe.

Classical theologians like Augustine and Thomas Aquinas saw it differently. They recognized that evil is not a created substance. Instead, evil is a privation of the good (privatio boni).

Defining evil as a privation doesn’t mean it isn’t real. The pain it causes is horrifying. But evil has no independent existence. It is not an original building block of reality.

It is simply the corruption or absence of something good. Think about rust. Rust isn’t a primary metal; it is the oxidation of iron. If all iron is removed, rust cannot exist.

Blindness is the impairment of sight. Cold is the absence of heat. Darkness is the absence of light. Moral evil works the same way.

God created the human will. Evil happens when that will turns away from its Maker. God created love, but lust is love’s selfish corruption. God created truth, but a lie perverts it.

God did not create evil because evil is not a “thing” to be made. It is the tragic corruption of what God made good.

God’s Good Creation

Scripture tells us that God is completely holy and untainted by wickedness. Genesis 1 establishes this baseline.

God spoke the cosmos into existence. After each creative act, He saw that it was good. At the climax of creation, God formed humanity in His image.

Genesis 1:31 says, “And God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good.” The Hebrew phrase is tov me’od. It means harmonious, beautiful, and fulfilling its divine purpose.

There was no flaw, malice, or decay in the original cosmos.

In Him Is No Darkness

The Bible insists that God’s nature is totally opposed to evil. Habakkuk 1:13 says, “You are of purer eyes than to behold evil, and cannot look on wickedness.”

In the New Testament, John confirms this absolute purity. He writes, “God is light and in Him is no darkness at all” (1 John 1:5).

James 1:13 shuts down any claim that God causes moral evil. “God cannot be tempted by evil, nor does He Himself tempt anyone.” God is the unchanging source of pure good.

did god

Did God Create Evil in Isaiah 45:7?

People who claim God is the author of evil often point to Isaiah 45:7 in the King James Version: “I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord do all these things.”

This 17th-century translation sounds jarring. But the original Hebrew vocabulary makes the meaning clear.

The Hebrew word translated “evil” in the KJV is ra’. While it can mean moral wickedness, it also means calamity, disaster, or hardship (Amos 3:6; Genesis 50:20).

Look at the verse’s poetic structure. “I form the light” pairs with “create darkness.” “I make peace (shalom)” pairs with “create ra’.”

The opposite of shalom (peace, safety, well-being) is not moral sin. It is disaster or calamity. Modern translations capture this accurately.

The ESV reads: “I make well-being and create calamity.” The NIV says: “I bring prosperity and create disaster.”

Isaiah 45:7 is not about God making moral evil. It shows God’s sovereignty over history. He brings peace to the humble and brings righteous judgment upon rebellious nations.

The Context of Isaiah 45

Isaiah addressed this prophecy to Cyrus the Great, king of Persia (Isaiah 45:1). Persian religion believed in two rival gods: a god of light and a god of darkness.

Through Isaiah, Yahweh dismantled this idea. There are not two ultimate cosmic powers. Yahweh alone rules light and darkness, peace and calamity.

God does not author sin. He was proving His supreme authority over all history to a pagan king.

How Did Evil Enter Creation?

If God did not create evil, where did it come from? Evil started through the voluntary rebellion of moral agents. They turned their freedom against their Creator.

When God made angels and humans, He didn’t make pre-programmed robots. He gave us genuine moral agency.

Love, worship, and obedience are impossible without the freedom to choose otherwise. A computer programmed to say “I love you” doesn’t actually love. Genuine love must be freely chosen.

This freedom carries the risk of rejection. God created the possibility of evil by granting free will. But it was the creature who turned that possibility into reality.

Scripture traces this rebellion first to the heavenly realm. Lucifer let pride corrupt him (Ezekiel 28:12-17). Then it reached human history in Genesis 3.

Adam and Eve chose autonomy over intimacy with God. By turning from the source of life, they brought spiritual death and decay into the world (Romans 5:12).

Permission vs. Causation

Theologians distinguish between primary and secondary causation. God sustains all reality (Colossians 1:17). However, He is not the culpable cause of sin.

When someone sins, God sustains their breath and the laws of nature. But the wicked intention belongs to the person. God sovereignly permits the act without authoring the sin.

God only permits evil because His wisdom can ultimately redeem it for a greater good (Romans 8:28).

Common Objections

1. If God foresaw evil, is He responsible?

Some argue that if God knew creation would result in suffering, He is to blame. But foreknowledge and moral culpability are different.

Parents know their future child will experience pain and commit wrongs. Yet having a child out of love is not cruel. The parents are not guilty of the child’s future sins.

God knew the cost of creation. Christ is “the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world” (Revelation 13:8). God decided a universe capable of genuine love was better than an empty void.

2. Does denying God created evil lead to Dualism?

Christianity rejects cosmic dualism. Evil is not an eternal reality alongside God. It is not a positive substance created by an anti-god.

Evil is a parasitic corruption inside good creatures who rebelled. Satan is not God’s equal opposite. He is a created being whose defeat is already guaranteed (Revelation 20:10).

3. Why hasn’t God destroyed evil yet?

If God is loving and powerful, why does evil persist? The Bible points to divine patience.

Peter explains: “The Lord is patient toward you, not wishing that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance” (2 Peter 3:9).

If God destroyed all evil tonight, none of us would survive. Every human heart harbors pride and selfishness. God delays His final judgment out of profound mercy, giving us time to find forgiveness in Christ.

The Cross and the Defeat of Evil

God didn’t stay distant and offer philosophical theories about evil. In the incarnation of Jesus Christ, God entered our brokenness.

Jesus took the full weight of human malice, betrayal, and suffering at Calvary.

Acts 2:23 says Jesus was “delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God” and killed by “lawless men.”

Lawless men acted with genuine wickedness. Yet God used their act to accomplish human salvation. On the cross, Jesus absorbed the curse of sin. By rising from the dead, He broke the power of evil forever.

Scripture promises the total eradication of evil in the New Creation. Revelation 21:4 says God will wipe away every tear, and death and pain will be no more.

God did not create evil. He bore its cost at Calvary, and He will destroy it forever.

Practical Applications

Knowing God is not the author of evil changes how we live and pray.

1. Anchor Your Trust in God’s Goodness

When tragedy strikes, our instinct is to resent God. We view Him as the orchestrator of our heartbreak. But God takes no pleasure in human ruin (Ezekiel 18:32).

This frees you to run to God rather than from Him. You are crying out to a Savior who wept at Lazarus’ tomb (John 11:35) and bore your grief on the cross. Trust that He is faithful to redeem your pain (Romans 8:28).

2. Take Responsibility for Your Sin

Ever since Eden, humans have blamed God for their choices. People excuse their greed or lust by saying, “That’s just how God made me.”

James 1:13-14 shatters this excuse. God tempts no one; we are enticed by our own desires. We have to take full responsibility for our sins. Stop projecting blame and start practicing honest confession (1 John 1:9).

3. Push Back the Darkness

Evil is a doomed intruder. Christians are not called to passive fatalism. We don’t just say, “Everything is broken, so it must be God’s will.”

Jesus taught us to pray for God’s will to be done on earth as it is in heaven (Matthew 6:10). When you feed the hungry, comfort the grieving, and share the Gospel, you push back the darkness. Overcome evil with good (Romans 12:21) until Christ makes all things new.