Skip to content
Bible & Scripture

The Apocrypha: Should These Books Be in Your Bible?

Daniel Cooper
Daniel Cooper · Biblical Studies Contributor
apocrypha books

Quick Answer: Catholic and Orthodox Bibles include the Apocrypha based on early Greek translations, while Protestants exclude them because they weren’t part of the original Hebrew canon affirmed by Jesus.

Open a Catholic or Eastern Orthodox Bible, and you might be surprised to find extra books. Tobit, Judith, 1 and 2 Maccabees, and the Wisdom of Solomon sit quietly between the Testaments.

This naturally prompts a question: What are these books, and should they be in your Bible? For many Christians, discovering this discrepancy is jarring. If the Bible is God’s Word, how can different traditions disagree on its actual contents?

We live in an era fascinated by lost books, hidden gospels, and religious conspiracies. The term “Apocrypha” sounds mysterious. It evokes images of dusty texts hidden away by religious authorities to suppress uncomfortable truths.

But history tells a different story. If we don’t know what the Bible actually is, we can’t trust what it says. We don’t need to fear this topic. Examining the history of the Apocrypha actually strengthens our confidence in the Bible we have today.

A Pastoral Note: It’s deeply unsettling to stumble across a TikTok or YouTube video claiming the church “hid” books of the Bible from you. I’ve sat with believers who felt entirely betrayed, wondering if their entire faith was built on a lie. If that’s where you are right now, take a breath. The history of how we got our Bible isn’t a shadowy conspiracy; it’s a very public, messy, and fascinating historical process. You don’t have to check your brain at the door to trust your Bible.

What Are the Apocrypha?

apocrypha and bible canon

The term Apocrypha comes from the Greek word apokryphos, meaning “hidden” or “concealed.” Originally, this wasn’t an insult. It just referred to books with unknown origins or those meant for an inner circle.

Over time, it became a catch-all term for ancient Jewish writings from the Intertestamental Period. This covers the 400 “silent years” between the prophet Malachi and John the Baptist.

What’s Actually in the Apocrypha?

The exact list varies depending on the tradition, but the core collection includes:

  • Historical Books: 1 and 2 Maccabees (covering the Jewish revolt against the Seleucid Empire).
  • Religious Fiction: Tobit, Judith, and Additions to Esther.
  • Wisdom Literature: The Wisdom of Solomon and Sirach.
  • Prophetic Books: Baruch, the Letter of Jeremiah, and 2 Esdras.
  • Additions to Daniel: The Prayer of Azariah, Susanna, and Bel and the Dragon.

Catholics call these books Deuterocanonical (“second canon”), viewing them as equal in authority to the rest of Scripture. Protestants call them Apocryphal, treating them as historically valuable but not divinely inspired.

The Greek Translation (Septuagint)

To understand the divide, we have to look at the Septuagint. During the 400 silent years, many Jews lived outside Israel and spoke Greek. Jewish scholars translated the Hebrew Scriptures into Greek to accommodate them.

This Greek translation, the Septuagint, became the go-to Bible for the early Christian church. Surviving manuscripts of the Septuagint include Apocryphal books mixed in with the standard Old Testament texts.

Because early Christians used this Greek translation, they were highly familiar with these extra books. But we don’t actually have a uniform “canon” of the Septuagint from the time of Christ. Different Greek manuscripts contained completely different Apocryphal books.

Should the Apocrypha Be in the Bible?

Determining what belongs in the Bible comes down to canonicity. The word “canon” comes from a Greek word meaning a measuring rod or standard. The canon refers to the collection of books that measure up to the standard of divine inspiration.

To figure out if the Apocrypha belongs in that collection, we have to look at history. We need to examine the Jewish people, Jesus, the early church, and the books themselves.

The Witness of the Jewish People

The Old Testament was originally entrusted to the Jewish people. As the Apostle Paul wrote, “the Jews have been entrusted with the very words of God” (Romans 3:2).

The Jewish community never accepted the Apocrypha as inspired Scripture. The Hebrew Bible contains the exact same books as the Protestant Old Testament.

First-century Jewish historian Josephus explicitly stated that the Jews only held to 22 authoritative books (which map perfectly to the 39 books of the Protestant Old Testament).

Josephus explained that while other historical records existed, they didn’t carry the same weight because “the exact succession of the prophets” had failed. The Jews believed prophetic inspiration ceased after Malachi. That is precisely when the Apocryphal books were being written.

The Witness of Jesus

The most compelling argument against the Apocrypha is the silence of Jesus and the apostles. The New Testament contains hundreds of direct quotes from the Old Testament. Jesus frequently appealed to Scripture by saying, “It is written.”

Yet, the New Testament never quotes an Apocryphal book as authoritative Scripture. While there are a few passing allusions to intertestamental history, an allusion isn’t an endorsement. Paul quoted pagan philosophers, but he didn’t consider their writings divinely inspired.

Jesus affirmed the traditional Jewish canon. In Luke 24:44, He referred to the standard three-fold division of the Hebrew Bible: the Law, the Prophets, and the Psalms.

He also summarized all the martyred prophets from “the blood of Abel to the blood of Zechariah” (Luke 11:51). Abel was the first martyr in Genesis. Zechariah was the last martyr in Chronicles (the final book in the Hebrew Bible’s arrangement). Jesus was summarizing the entire Hebrew canon from A to Z. The Apocrypha wasn’t included.

The Witness of the Early Church

The early church’s relationship with the Apocrypha was messy. Because early Christians used the Greek Septuagint, many church fathers read and valued these extra books.

But when church leaders sat down to officially define the canon, they drew a hard line. Melito of Sardis traveled to Palestine around AD 170 to verify the exact Old Testament books. His resulting list matches the Protestant canon. Athanasius did the same in AD 367, explicitly stating the Apocrypha was useful for reading but not part of the canon.

Jerome, the scholar who translated the Bible into Latin, drew a sharp distinction between canonical books and the Apocrypha. He noted that while the church read these books for historical instruction, they should never be used to establish theology.

It wasn’t until the Council of Trent in 1546 that the Roman Catholic Church officially declared the Apocrypha to be inspired Scripture. This was largely a reaction against the Protestant Reformers, who had returned to the original Hebrew canon.

Errors and Contradictions

The Apocryphal books never actually claim divine inspiration for themselves. They lack the authoritative “Thus says the LORD” found throughout the prophets. In fact, 1 Maccabees openly admits that there were no active prophets during its era.

When you read the texts closely, you also find stark historical and theological contradictions:

  1. Theological Errors:
    • Salvation by Works: Tobit 12:9 claims, “For almsgiving saves from death and purges away every sin.” This directly contradicts the biblical teaching of justification by faith alone.
    • Praying for the Dead: 2 Maccabees commends offering sacrifices to free the dead from their sins. The Catholic Church leaned heavily on this passage to defend Purgatory and the sale of indulgences during the Reformation.
  2. Historical Errors:
    • The book of Judith claims Nebuchadnezzar was the king of the Assyrians in Nineveh. He was actually the king of the Babylonians in Babylon.
    • Tobit’s timeline is completely fractured, placing him alive during events that happened hundreds of years apart, contradicting his own stated lifespan.

These errors make it clear why the early church largely kept these books separate. They are historically interesting, but they lack the fingerprint of divine inspiration.

apocrypha and

Common Objections

Didn’t the early church universally use the Apocrypha? Many early Christians read the Apocrypha simply because it was bound with their Greek Bibles. But using a book doesn’t make it canonical. The most educated scholars of the early church consistently separated the authoritative Hebrew canon from the Apocryphal books.

Did Martin Luther remove the Apocrypha from the Bible? Luther didn’t remove the Apocrypha. He actually translated it and included it in his German Bible in a separate section between the Testaments. His preface explicitly stated they were “not held equal to the Holy Scriptures, and yet are profitable and good to read.” Modern Protestant Bibles only stopped printing them in the 19th century to save on printing costs.

Doesn’t the New Testament quote the Apocrypha? There are zero direct quotations of the Apocrypha in the New Testament. There are thematic parallels, which just proves the New Testament writers lived in a culture familiar with these books. Alluding to a cultural text is not the same as granting it divine authority.

Why This Matters Today

Understanding the Apocrypha isn’t just about winning a theological trivia game. It impacts how we view and trust God’s Word.

  1. Confidence in your Bible: You can trust that the 66 books in your Protestant Bible are exactly what God intended. The canon wasn’t formed by a heavy-handed church council centuries later. It was organically recognized by God’s people from the very beginning.
  2. Valuing history without elevating it: We don’t need to fear or vilify the Apocrypha. Books like 1 Maccabees are immensely valuable for understanding Jewish history between the Testaments. They explain the cultural landscape Jesus entered, including the rise of the Pharisees. We can read these books for historical background while maintaining a clear boundary between human history and divine revelation.
  3. Gracious dialogue: Knowing this history equips you to have charitable conversations with Catholic or Orthodox friends. Instead of throwing accusations about “adding” or “subtracting” from the Bible, you can discuss the historical nuances of the Greek translation and the Council of Trent.

The Apocrypha offers a fascinating window into ancient Jewish thought. But it remains exactly what early scholars declared it to be: separate from the canon, yet profitable for historical context. The true, inspired Word of God stands secure.