Skip to content
Gospel of Luke Humility & Prayer

The Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector

Two men pray in the temple. The Pharisee prays proudly about his accomplishments. The tax collector beats his breast and says only, 'God, have mercy on me.'

Luke 18:9-14

This may be the most psychologically precise thing Jesus ever said about prayer.

In two brief portraits — less than six verses — he exposes the difference between religion as performance and prayer as encounter. Between talking at God and crying to God. Between the person who enters the temple to inform God of their spiritual record, and the person who enters because they have nowhere else to go.

Luke tells us exactly who this parable was aimed at: “certain which trusted in themselves that they were righteous, and despised others” (Luke 18:9). Two thousand years later, the target hasn’t moved.

The Story (Luke 18:10-14)

“Two men went up into the temple to pray; the one a Pharisee, and the other a publican.” (Luke 18:10, KJV)

The Pharisee was the religious elite of first-century Judaism. A Pharisee tithed everything down to the garden herbs. He fasted twice a week (Monday and Thursday, days not commanded by the Law but chosen for extra devotion). He knew the Torah better than almost anyone. By every external measure, he was the most religious person in the room.

The publican (tax collector) was the opposite. He worked for Rome, collecting taxes from his own Jewish neighbors — and was culturally permitted to add his own surcharge on top. He was considered a traitor, a collaborator, and a thief. Rabbis classified tax collectors with robbers. They were excluded from synagogues, their money was considered tainted, their testimony inadmissible in courts.

These are the two most religiously polarized characters in Jesus’ world — and he puts them both in the temple on the same day.

The Pharisee’s Prayer

“The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, God, I thank thee, that I am not as other men are, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even as this publican. I fast twice in the week, I give tithes of all that I possess.” (Luke 18:11-12, KJV)

The phrase “prayed thus with himself” is devastating. The Greek pros heauton — literally “toward himself.” His prayer never actually reached God. It was a monologue directed inward — or perhaps outward, at the tax collector he had already noticed and categorized.

His content is structured as a comparison. He defines his righteousness not by God’s standard but by contrast with others:

  • “I am not as other men” — extortioners, unjust, adulterers
  • “Or even as this publican” — he points to the specific man in the corner

Then his credentials: fasting twice weekly, tithing on everything. These were genuine religious acts, and the Pharisee had genuinely done them. He was not lying. He was simply doing the most dangerous thing a religious person can do: using his genuine religious performance as the basis for his standing before God.

His prayer begins with “I thank thee” — but what follows is not gratitude. It is a resume.

Related Study: The Parable of the Dragnet

The Tax Collector’s Prayer

“And the publican, standing afar off, would not lift up so much as his eyes unto heaven, but smote upon his breast, saying, God be merciful to me a sinner.” (Luke 18:13, KJV)

Every physical detail signals the opposite of the Pharisee:

  • “Standing afar off” — he did not approach the inner courts where the Pharisee presumably stood. He kept his distance, as if aware of his unworthiness to be there at all.
  • “Would not lift up so much as his eyes unto heaven” — the normal posture for Jewish prayer was eyes and hands raised. He could not do it.
  • “Smote upon his breast” — beating the chest was a gesture of grief and self-accusation. Not a liturgical performance — a physical expression of internal anguish.
  • “God be merciful to me a sinner” — in the Greek: ho theos, hilasthēti moi tō hamartōlō. Literally: “The God, be propitiated toward me, the sinner.”

The word hilasthēti is the verbal form of hilasmos — the same word used for the atoning work of Christ (1 John 2:2, 4:10). He is asking not merely for God’s sympathy or leniency, but for the covering of wrath, for atonement. And he calls himself not “a sinner” as in one among many — he uses the definite article: “the sinner.” The chief one. The worst.

Explore: The Parable of the Fig Tree

The Verdict

“I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other: for every one that exalteth himself shall be abased; and he that humbleth himself shall be exalted.” (Luke 18:14, KJV)

The word dedikaiōmenos — justified — is the great Pauline word of salvation. Declared righteous. The legal metaphor: a verdict of “not guilty” before God’s court.

Jesus gives this verdict to the tax collector. The man who broke God’s law and his community’s trust walked out of the temple in right standing with God. The man who kept every rule walked out without it.

This is not a statement that sin doesn’t matter. It is a statement about how a person becomes right with God. Not by accumulating religious credits, but by honest, humble, helpless dependence on God’s mercy.

Dive Deeper: The Parable of the Friend at Midnight

Why the Pharisee’s Prayer Failed

The Pharisee’s prayer failed not because he lied, not because his religious acts were worthless, but because of what his prayer revealed about his posture toward God:

  1. He was self-sufficient. He came to inform God of his standing, not to receive from God. He had nothing to ask for because in his view he lacked nothing.

  2. He measured himself by humans, not by God. “I am not as other men” — but the standard for the human heart is not the tax collector. It is the holiness of God. Compared to God’s perfection, every religious resume collapses.

  3. He despised others. Luke tells us the parable was told to those who “despised others.” You cannot love God and despise the image-bearer of God across the room. The contempt for the tax collector was itself evidence of the spiritual poverty the Pharisee couldn’t see.

The Most Important Prayer in the Bible?

Martin Luther called this prayer of the tax collector — “God, be merciful to me a sinner” — the foundation of all true prayer. You can build an entire theology of prayer on seven words:

  • God — not a vague higher power, but the God who is there, the God who hears
  • be merciful — a request, not a demand; an admission of need, not a claim of right
  • to me — personal, not theoretical; this isn’t about sinners in general
  • a sinner — honest self-assessment, without excuse or comparison

When you don’t know what to pray, this is where to start.

Related Study: The Parable of the Good Shepherd

How to Apply This Today

  1. Audit your prayers. Are you bringing God your needs or your resume? Do you find yourself, in prayer, cataloguing your faithfulness — your church attendance, your giving, your service — as though building a case? Notice it. Stop.

  2. Stop comparing yourself to others in your prayers. “At least I’m not like that person” is the Pharisee’s grammar. Drop it. The standard is Christ. Against that standard, we all need the tax collector’s prayer.

  3. Pray the tax collector’s prayer. Literally. Today. “God, be merciful to me, a sinner.” Seven words. Let them be the foundation under everything else you bring to God.

  4. Notice your posture. The tax collector stood “afar off” — not because God requires physical distance, but because his inner posture was one of radical humility. What is your inner posture in prayer?

  5. Remember: justified means justified. The tax collector left the temple in right standing with God — despite his failures. You don’t have to earn your way back. You have to come honestly.

“God be merciful to me a sinner.” (Luke 18:13, KJV)

Explore All of Jesus' Parables

Browse all 40+ parables with meaning, context, and real application for daily life.